http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2012/02/06/the_untouchable
The 'Untouchable'
Meet Mayawati, India's multimillionaire lower-caste power broker and politician.
BY SADANAND DHUME | FEBRUARY 6, 2012
Millions of voters will head to the polls this week for the first
phase of what are often called India's second-most important elections
-- for a new government in Uttar Pradesh, the country's largest state
and home to about one in six of its 1.2 billion citizens. If it were
an independent country, UP, as it is commonly known, would be the
world's fifth-most populous, roughly the size of Brazil.
In the drama of Indian democracy, UP has always played a starring
role. Eight of India's 13 prime ministers, including Jawaharlal Nehru
and Indira Gandhi, have come from the Hindi heartland state, which
sits along India's northern border with Nepal. UP is also home to the
parliamentary constituencies of Nehru's heirs, Congress party leader
Sonia Gandhi and her son, Rahul Gandhi, arguably the country's two
most powerful politicians.
In recent weeks, the media has dwelled upon the 41-year-old Gandhi
scion's effort to reclaim UP for Congress for the first time since
1989. Few expect him to pull this off: India's ruling party holds only
22 seats in the 403-strong state assembly. Nonetheless, a strong
performance will be interpreted by pundits and party insiders as a
sign of Gandhi's readiness this year to replace Singh as prime
minister, an office held by Gandhi's great-grandfather, grandmother,
and father before him.
Standing in Gandhi's way is a streetwise 56-year-old politician with a
starkly different pedigree. One of nine children born in a New Delhi
shantytown to a postal clerk and his illiterate wife, Chief Minister
Mayawati (she uses only one name) leads UP's ruling Bahujan Samaj
Party (BSP), best known as the party of India's Dalits -- the people
once called "untouchables" -- who comprise about 16 percent of the
country's population.
Historically, Dalits occupied the lowest rung of Indian society,
beyond the pale of the four-tiered caste system. Members of Mayawati's
Chamar subcaste were traditionally leather workers, a trade considered
unclean in Hinduism. In American terms, Mayawati's position is roughly
akin to a granddaughter of slaves being elected governor of New York
just a half-century after the abolition of slavery.
Thanks to UP's electoral weight and political symbolism, should
Mayawati win another term -- she's been in power since the last
election in 2007 -- she will be one step closer to her stated goal of
becoming prime minister (though her limited appeal outside her home
state still makes her a long shot). Even if she loses, though, the
chief minister will remain a symbol of both the promise and the perils
of India's burgeoning democracy.
For Mayawati's many detractors, she's a vivid reminder of everything
that's wrong with Indian politics. Soon after she became chief
minister of UP for the first time in 1995 -- she has lost and returned
to the office three times since then -- Mayawati earned a reputation
for megalomania, staggering corruption, and the privileging of narrow
identity politics above the most elementary norms of governance.
Understatement is not Mayawati's strong suit. In 2003, the
diamond-bedecked chief minister reportedly spent 100 million taxpayer
rupees (roughly $2 million) on a lavish party for her birthday,
celebrated by her supporters each year as swabhiman divas, or
self-respect day. The trappings included a 110-pound cake, 100,000
laddoos -- a traditional Indian sweet -- more than 13,000 pounds of
marigolds, 5,000 bouquets of flowers, and decorations mimicking a
classic Bollywood movie set during the Mughal Empire.
In a similar display of garishness at a BSP event two years ago,
Mayawati's supporters presented her with a giant garland of rupees
valued at between $400,000 and $2 million. A much-discussed WikiLeaks
cable released last year described her as a "virtual paranoid
dictator" who made errant ministers do sit-ups before her as penance
and dispatched a private jet to Mumbai to pick up her preferred brand
of sandals. Mayawati denied the allegations and suggested that Julian
Assange be thrown into a mental asylum in her state.
When not burnishing her cult of personality with public displays of
excess, Mayawati finds other ways to set her critics' teeth on edge.
They attack her for ignoring poverty and pouring vast resources into
grand memorials to Dalit heroes, foremost among them Bhimrao Ambedkar,
a Columbia University-educated Dalit lawyer who rose from poverty to
become the prime author of India's Constitution. The chief minister
has dotted the state with statues of Ambedkar -- and in recent years
of herself clutching a trademark rectangular handbag.
Then there's the grand-scale corruption. Among the most notable
allegations are lucrative government jobs auctioned to the highest
bidder, embezzlement and land grabbing near the Taj Mahal, and the
alleged looting of a national health-care program that has led to the
mysterious deaths of at least three people in what is widely viewed as
a coverup.
In 2010, Mayawati declared her net worth as 880 million rupees (about
$17.9 million at current exchange rates), which made her, at least on
paper, one of India's richest politicians. Her holdings include
commercial real estate and two mansions in one of New Delhi's toniest
neighborhoods. The chief minister's once humble family has also
prospered during her time in public life. Specifics are hard to come
by, but according to a 2003 court filing by India's Central Bureau of
Investigation, Mayawati and her family owned scores of shops, houses,
and orchards. At least one of her brothers is a controversial
businessman accused of prospering because of proximity to power.
Mayawati brushes off corruption allegations as part of a conspiracy by
jealous upper-caste elites to tar her image. Her wealth, she says,
comes from donations from her admirers, especially Dalits who look up
to behenji, or elder sister, as she is known among the BSP faithful.
Despite the well-founded complaints, there is a more generous way to
view the chief minister. Only in a true democracy could the power of
the ballot overturn millennia of discrimination. Outsiders may scoff
at her statue-building spree, but for UP's 40 million Dalits who view
her as a modern-day messiah, the symbolism of public spaces honoring a
group that has been ritually humiliated for centuries can hardly be
called empty.
As for Mayawati's cult of personality, her opponents are hardly in the
best position to criticize. Over the years, Congress Party governments
have poured untold millions of taxpayer rupees into government
programs named after members of the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty: They too
have their memorials and museums, not to mention stadiums, airports,
and universities. Nor can anyone say with authority that the chief
minister is in fact wealthier than many of her peers in politics. If
anything, she may merely be guilty of flaunting what others prefer to
veil.
In a broader sense, the Dalit movement that Mayawati leads has become
less rough around the edges over the years. In the 1980s, when it was
led by Mayawati's mentor, BSP-founder Kanshi Ram, its message focused
almost exclusively on hatred of the upper castes. A popular slogan
from the 1980s called on Dalits to take off their shoes and thrash
Brahmins, Kshatriyas, and Vaishyas, the three highest castes. In 1995,
when Mayawati briefly became chief minister of UP for the first time,
she appeared to spend more time pursuing vendettas against upper-caste
civil servants than governing. A small coterie of Dalit civil servants
and police officers monopolized power, and caste was widely viewed as
trumping all other considerations in government postings.
In the last election, by contrast, Mayawati came to power with a
majority in the state legislature -- rather than in a shaky coalition
as in the past -- thanks to the broadening of her appeal beyond her
Dalit base. Most remarkably, the Dalit leader drew significant Brahmin
support. Similarly, in the current election, less than a quarter of
the BSP's candidates are Dalits.
The BSP does not profess much of an ideology beyond a gauzy vision of
social uplift, but Mayawati has broadened her appeal by promising
greater inclusiveness, improved law and order, and support for sops
such as government jobs for the upper-caste poor. Under her rule,
economic growth has picked up to a shade below the national average of
7 percent. Her government has built 200,000 houses for the
disadvantaged. In October, somewhat incongruously, Mayawati presided
over India's first ever Formula 1 race on a brand-new track on the
outskirts of Delhi.
This doesn't mean that there isn't significant room for improvement.
The state continues to lag its more dynamic peers in western and
southern India by virtually every measure of income and human
development. For some, UP is synonymous with underweight babies and
rampant illiteracy. (About 30 percent of UP's people can't read or
write.) Hundreds died last year in an outbreak of viral encephalitis.
As for UP's commitment to democracy, sometimes it can be difficult to
tell the state's criminals from its legislators.
Despite the historical significance of a Dalit woman's rise to become
what political commentator Ajoy Bose calls "the undisputed empress of
India's largest state," symbolism alone does not equal progress. It
shouldn't be too much for UP's voters to expect politicians who can
offer their supporters more than just a dose of self-respect. We won't
know the outcome of UP's elections until next month. The smart money
is on Mayawati's traditional rival, another lower-caste (but not
Dalit) regional outfit, the Samajwadi Party. But one thing is for
sure: Whoever is elected has their work cut out for them.
INFORMATION OVERLOAD?
Get all ZESTCaste mails sent out in a span of 24 hours in a single mail. Subscribe to the daily digest version by sending a blank mail to ZESTMedia-digest@yahoogroups.com, OR, if you have a Yahoo! Id, change your settings at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/join/
PARTICIPATE:-
On this list you can share caste news, discuss caste issues and network with like-minded anti-caste people from across India and the world. Just write to zestcaste@yahoogroups.com
TELL FRIENDS TO SIGN UP:-
If you got this mail as a forward, subscribe to ZESTCaste by sending a blank mail to ZESTCaste-subscribe@yahoogroups.com OR, if you have a Yahoo! ID, by visiting http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/join/
Also have a look at our sister list, ZESTMedia: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/
No comments:
Post a Comment