Monday, January 23, 2012

[ZESTCaste] Republic of contradictions (Opinion)

Republic of contradictions

January 24, 2012
By Jagmohan

Sixty three years ago, Dr B.R. Ambedkar spoke of the "life of
contradictions" into which the Indian Republic would enter on January
26, 1950.

He underlined the need for eliminating, at the earliest, the
contradictions in the social and economic sphere lest they should
imperil our political freedom and democracy. Were he to come alive
today, he would be appalled to see the extent to which the
contradictions have deepened and, that too during the period when the
Republic saw one of the fastest growing economies in the world.

A report by the Naadi Foundation on Hunger and Malnutrition, which was
released by the Prime Minister on January 11, 2012, has brought out
that "59 per cent of the Indian children, between the age group of 0-5
years, have stunted growth, 42 per cent are underweight and 11 per
cent suffer from wasting disease". Every year, 13 lakh children die
before reaching their first birthday, and about 55,000 women lose
their life consequent upon birth-related complications.

Even now, as noted by the Unicef, in its report of 2009, 40 per cent
of the world's child marriages occur in India" and "about 47 per cent
of Indian women in the age group of 20 to 24 years, covered by the
survey, were found to have been married off before attaining the legal
age of 18".

It is the socially and culturally sanctioned practices and not the
provision of law that generally matter.

Many other recent reports prepared by reputed agencies, both national
and international, have reminded us of the agonising reality that has
continued to curl around the body politic of our Republic, and with
which we have been dealing without much zeal or inner commitment. The
"human development index" value assigned to India in the 2011 report
of the United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) is substantially

It is merely 0.547, and goes down further to 0.392 if the element of
inequality is factored in. India's overall rank is 134 amongst 187
countries covered by the report. Her position on "gender inequality
index" is no less dismal; India is 129th in the list of 146 countries
surveyed. When measured on the UNDP's "multi-dimensional poverty
index", about 53 per cent of the total population of India would have
to be reckoned as poor and living under distress.

It is primarily on account of this distress that in 2010 alone as many
as 15,968 farmers and 28,152 self-employed persons in industry, trade
and other professions committed suicide. The ever-increasing migrants
to the major Indian cities are finding shelter only in the hell-hole
of slums.

About 38 million of them are afflicted with serious water-borne
diseases. Over half of the world's most polluted cities are in India.
Because of the poor quality of air, 18,000 premature deaths and 1.7
crore cases of illness occur each year in Delhi, Mumbai, Kolkata and

What makes the above conditions all the more tragic is that they have
persisted even when India is virtually witnessing a "Gilded Age" of
nouveau billionaires and when luxury houses, posh malls and sprawling
golf courses are sprouting like mushroom in its metropolises. India's
capital, Delhi, alone has been, on an average, adding about 1,000
motor vehicles on roads every day. The contradictions that the
Republic is rearing are, indeed, unprecedented.

It is the poor governance capacity of our system as a whole that has
badly let the Republic down. In this regard, bureaucracy has to share
a major part of the blame. The Indian Civil Services, which
constituted the steel frame of the administrative setup at the time of
Independence, had justifiably earned the reputation of being the best
in the world; otherwise how could a mere 1,000 members of the service
effectively maintain law and order throughout the length and breadth
of British India and also carry out such remarkable development
projects as setting up of an extensive network of canal irrigation in
Punjab and Uttar Pradesh?

The remnants of this service and its successor, IAS, served the
Republic well for the first few years of its life and played a
prominent role in the integration of 562 princely states,
rehabilitation of displaced persons and ushering in of the Green
Revolution. But, due to the emergence of narrow politics of power and
uncongenial social and cultural environment, the services started
losing their verve, vitality and moral pie. They were soon
overburdened with junk, and their interior spaces were infested with
all types of pests.

Now, the Indian bureaucracy as a class is being labelled as
obstructionist and venal. A Hongkong-based research group, named
Political and Economic Risk Consultancy, in its report of January
2012, has rated this bureaucracy as "the worst in Asia". That this
appellation is not uncalled for can be seen from the fact that the
2011 report of the ministry of programme implementation itself shows
that the delay in executing the plan projects would cost the public
exchequer an additional amount of Rs 1.20 lakh crore.

The system of education in the Republic, too, has been marred by its
unwholesome development. The recent data shows that 38 per cent of the
doctors, 36 per cent of the Nasa technicians and 34 per cent of
Microsoft employees working in the US are Indians and that they have
mostly Indian educational background. But the other side of the
system's reality is that at present about two-thirds of universities
and about 90 per cent of colleges are performing below average.

In respect of school education, January 2012 report of the
Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development regarding its
International Student Assessment Programme has ranked Indian higher
secondary students only better than those from Kyrgyzstan among 74
participating countries.

On its birthday, all the well-wishers of the Republic should ponder
over what the future holds for her. Would her freedom, in view of
social and economic contradictions that her system is engendering, be
blown up, as apprehended by Ambedkar, or would she turn a new page in
her life?

W.E. Channing, a famous unitarian preacher of the 19th century, had
made a highly insightful observation about the manner in which a setup
undergoes a fundamental transformation: "There are seasons, in human
affairs, of inward and outward revolution, when new depths seem to be
broken up in the soul, when new wants are unfolded in multitudes, and
a new and undefined good is thirsted for. There are periods when the
principles of experience need to be modified, when hope and trust and
instincts claim a share with prudence in the guidance of affairs,
when, in truth, to dare is the highest wisdom."

I am not sure whether a season for inward and outward revolution has
come for India, whether new depths would break up in her soul, whether
a new and undefined good would be thirsted for by her, whether hope
and trust and instinct would claim a share with her prudence and
whether she would attain her highest wisdom by daring.

But I have no doubt that unless the Indian Republic is soon visited by
such a season of inward and outward revolution and she attains her
highest wisdom by daring, she faces a bleak future and her
contradictions and crudities would multiply and assume a more sinister

The writer is a former governor of J&K and a former Union minister


Get all ZESTCaste mails sent out in a span of 24 hours in a single mail. Subscribe to the daily digest version by sending a blank mail to, OR, if you have a Yahoo! Id, change your settings at

On this list you can share caste news, discuss caste issues and network with like-minded anti-caste people from across India and the world. Just write to

If you got this mail as a forward, subscribe to ZESTCaste by sending a blank mail to OR, if you have a Yahoo! ID, by visiting

Also have a look at our sister list, ZESTMedia:! Groups Links

<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:

<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional

<*> To change settings online go to:
(Yahoo! ID required)

<*> To change settings via email:

<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:

<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:

No comments:

Post a Comment

Blog Archive