January 17, 2012
Affirmative-Action Foe Is Facing Allegations of Financial Misdeeds
By CHARLIE SAVAGE
WASHINGTON — Ward Connerly, the black businessman who has been the
face of the movement to end affirmative action for nearly two decades,
is facing accusations from a prominent former ally that he has
mismanaged — and exploited for his own benefit — donations to that
cause made by fellow conservatives.
Moreover, a group Mr. Connerly founded to advance government policies
that are race and gender neutral, the Sacramento-based American Civil
Rights Institute, is under investigation by the Internal Revenue
Service and by the attorney general of California, according to
documents and interviews.
Mr. Connerly has faced accusations of profiteering before, as
supporters of affirmative action highlighted his salary in an effort
to discredit his cause. But this time, the allegations are more
detailed and come from another significant movement figure: Jennifer
Gratz, the named plaintiff in a landmark 2003 Supreme Court case that
struck down a race-based admissions policy at the University of
After she won that case, Mr. Connerly hired Ms. Gratz to conduct
research and run campaigns supporting anti-affirmative action ballot
initiatives. She resigned last September and, through her lawyer, sent
the group's board a five-page letter, a copy of which was obtained by
The New York Times.
"For years, Ms. Gratz was aware of the allegations that Mr. Connerly
received excessive compensation," it said. "She presumed that the
issue was politically motivated and raised solely by opponents of the
organization's mission. It has come to her attention, however, that
there may be some merit to the allegations of financial impropriety."
Interviewed by phone and e-mail, Mr. Connerly, 72, acknowledged that
his group had had financial difficulties, but said its board had not
responded to the letter because "90 percent" of it was false. He
portrayed Ms. Gratz as a "disgruntled former employee" trying to
"besmirch me personally" because she wanted to replace him.
The letter was written by Ms. Gratz's lawyer, Robert N. Driscoll, a
former deputy assistant attorney general for civil rights in the
administration of George W. Bush. In a statement, through him, she
said: "I thought it was important to make sure all board members were
aware of what was going on even if doing so was unfortunate, sad and
uncomfortable and even though it meant that I had to resign from a
position within a cause that I will always hold near and dear."
The dispute is alarming allies.
"I'm sorry to hear this because I'm a great admirer of both of them,"
said Roger Clegg, the president of the Center for Equal Opportunity,
which also opposes affirmative action. "She is a courageous, smart
person — and Ward is also a courageous, smart person."
A businessman and a former University of California regent, Mr.
Connerly rose to fame in 1996 as the backer of a successful ballot
initiative barring public institutions in California from taking race
or gender into account. He later founded the institute and a related
advocacy group and continued to call for "colorblind government" in
matters like contracting and college admissions.
Ms. Gratz's letter alleges a series of financial irregularities,
starting with Mr. Connerly's pay.
Late last summer, the institute belatedly filed disclosure forms for
tax years ending in June 2008, 2009, and 2010. (The I.R.S. that summer
had revoked the tax-exempt status of its related advocacy group for
failing to file such forms.) They showed that his annual pay was
between $1.2 million and $1.5 million each year — more than half its
Because charitable donations are tax deductible, according to I.R.S.
rules no employee may get excessive compensation. Two other nonprofit
groups opposing affirmative action, the Center for Equal Opportunity
and the Center for Individual Rights, pay their leaders about $144,000
and $250,000, respectively.
Mr. Connerly said that "every penny which I receive is directly
related to our mission," and that he used some of his salary to pay
others for research and legal work. He also said the group had reduced
his pay to $850,000.
One reason Mr. Connerly has been a particularly effective advocate is
that he is black. Mr. Clegg said there were "few people who can do or
would do what he does," adding that it is hard to set a salary on a
job that requires enduring racially charged name-calling from fellow
A major financial supporter is the Lynde and Harry Bradley Foundation.
Its president, Michael W. Grebe, said he was "very comfortable" that
its donations to Mr. Connerly's group were "being spent for public
"He's very effective," Mr. Grebe said.
Ms. Gratz's letter contends that the group has been "in financial
crisis since March 2010" in part because of Mr. Connerly's salary and
legal fees related to the tax investigations, and has "ceased almost
entirely" doing projects furthering its mission since June 2011.
Her letter also says the group has had trouble making payroll and
"knowingly" under-reported what it paid employees on payroll tax forms
— "irregularities" that "partly result from disruptions in revenue"
but that "also appear to be designed to facilitate Mr. Connerly's high
Mr. Connerly denied such allegations as "speculation and conjecture,"
saying Ms. Gratz was not privy to administrative details. He also said
educational activities by him and his group were "instrumental" in
passing an anti-affirmative action initiative in Arizona in November
2010, and in laying the groundwork for a vote on a similar measure in
Oklahoma set for fall 2012.
Ms. Gratz's letter said five of the group's eight employees "are
family members" or have "personal or nonprofessional relationships
with Mr. Connerly," and raised questions about its "contracts for
services and leases."
For example, the letter said, the group contracted with a former
longtime employee of Mr. Connerly's profit-making firm to create a
report on Oklahoma, for up to 120 hours at $60 an hour; it "consisted
mainly of printouts from Wikipedia."
While the letter did not explain its reference to "leases," the
group's recent tax filings show that its rent tripled, to just under
$70,000, after it moved to a different building about four years ago.
Records show a group employee purchased the building in February 2008
for about $444,000.
Mr. Connerly said hiring people he knew was appropriate, given his
group's "controversial" mission. He also said he had instructed the
employee to find new offices because they needed more room, and he
approved the arrangement she had made.
Despite his salary, Mr. Connerly acknowledged that he had had
financial difficulties; public records show that in 2010 and 2011,
several hundred thousand dollars in liens for unpaid taxes were
leveled against him. He said he was working on paying what he owed. In
addition, a disclosure form filed with the IRS says the institute
discovered last year that Mr. Connerly had submitted "unsubstantiated"
business expenses from his credit card and cellphone bills. He had
paid back $10,000 as of September, but still owed about $24,000.
Ms. Gratz was once Mr. Connerly's defender. In 2008, when
anti-affirmative action initiatives were on the ballot in Colorado and
Nebraska, a liberal group ran ads portraying him as supporting such
measures so he could pocket "nonprofit slush funds."
Ms. Gratz made a video denouncing the ads as character assassination.
But, her letter said, she subsequently realized that Mr. Connerly's
group had "not been adequate stewards of the resources the donors
entrusted to the organization," adding that she "will cooperate with
any government investigation."
Kitty Bennett contributed research.
Get all ZESTCaste mails sent out in a span of 24 hours in a single mail. Subscribe to the daily digest version by sending a blank mail to ZESTMediaemail@example.com, OR, if you have a Yahoo! Id, change your settings at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/join/
On this list you can share caste news, discuss caste issues and network with like-minded anti-caste people from across India and the world. Just write to firstname.lastname@example.org
TELL FRIENDS TO SIGN UP:-
If you got this mail as a forward, subscribe to ZESTCaste by sending a blank mail to ZESTCasteemail@example.com OR, if you have a Yahoo! ID, by visiting http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/join/
Also have a look at our sister list, ZESTMedia: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
<*> Your email settings:
Individual Email | Traditional
<*> To change settings online go to:
(Yahoo! ID required)
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to: