Dalits and Tribals apprehensive of the Lokpal
A huge rally in the heart of the Capital asks the government to not
meddle with the Constitution
Hardnews Bureau Delhi
Hundreds of Dalits and Tribals marched from Ramlila Maidan to Jantar
Mantar on November 28, demanding that their fears be addressed before
a strong Lokpal Bill is passed by Parliament. And that any decision
should not happen at the cost of the Constitutional measures in place
for the backward strata of society. The rally was ignored by almost
all the mainstream publications and television channels.
Many Dalit and other backward sections feel left out and they see the
Anna Hazare led anti-graft campaign as a ploy to take the attention
away from issues concerning affirmative action for them. Also, there
have been allegations that the India Against Corruption leadership is
anti-Dalit and anti-reservation. Here is the full text of a press
statement by the organisers.
Today, hundreds of thousands of Dalits and tribals took out a massive
rally under the leadership of Dr Uditraj from Ramlila Maidan to Jantar
Mantar for even those causes which could have been fulfilled much
before. Progressive citizens regardless of their caste and religion
participated and, of course, OBCs and minorities also extended their
full solidarity for the cause.
There is increasing awareness in so far as corruption is concerned.
Due to corruption, price rise and support of media, this issue has
gained phenomenal currency. We are for strong Lokpal Bill but that
should not happen at the cost of sovereignty of the people which is
vested in the Constitution.
There is no alternative to democracy and hence the need is to improve
and revamp the same rather than to discredit it. In a democracy, the
government is a byproduct of the society and to see the bureaucracy
and politics without linking it to society will be fallacious and such
attempts have been made in recent past. It is not the law alone which
fulfills its objectives rather the people of the society who apply and
it depends on their support as to what extent they are willing to
follow it. The Lokpal Bill is going to be enacted and if the dalits,
tribals, OBCs and minorities are alienated from the beginning, even if
we get a strong Lokpal, chances are there that it may fail for lack of
cooperation from all sections of the society. Though India is known to
be a melting pot of different nationalities, cultures and traditions
but caste has not melted away. And in this background, it is of utmost
necessity to provide reservation to the SC/ST/OBC and minorities in
the Lokpal Committee. Their exclusion will lead to discrimination at
the level of investigation and prosecution in the matters of
Dr Udit Raj spoke that the confederation has already submitted
Bahujan Lokpal Bill before the Standing Committee of Parliament and
had pressed for the above demand and also strongly advocated for
inclusion of NGOs and corporate houses in the ambit of the Lokpal.
Enormous amount of funds are allocated through special component plans
for SC and sub-tribal plans for ST but due to corruption and
malpractices, the desired level of amelioration of these communities
has not been achieved. The government is urged that the Lokpal bill is
passed in current Parliament session only but after addressing these
The economic pursuit of a person in a caste based society is not fixed
by the education, training, expertise, exposure and capacity and
interest of the person rather depends on the social status of the
person received from his parents. Centuries and millennia of
backwardness cannot be removed in a few decades. When Indians were not
in a position to compete with the British in ICS, agitations were
launched to accommodate them. There used to be only two divisions,
first and second and Indians were not passing the examination, then
Indian British government was urged to introduce third division so
that Indians could qualify the exams. This also supports that it takes
generations for any community to reach a level playing field.
Dalits and tribals have been deprived of land, natural resources,
dignity, administration, education, knowledge for millennia and
therefore, they still need protection with a view to maintain them in
Globalization and privatization have pushed them back and more jobs
are coming in private sector and hence reservation in private sector
is justified demand not only to empower them rather to strengthen the
unity and integrity of the country. Progress of the country is not
possible as long as such a large section of population is deprived.
The developed countries like US have strong affirmative programmes for
their deprived people and private sector is coming forward gladly to
include them but in our case, the corporate houses are opposing under
the pretext of merit and efficiency. So far, due to reservation, it
has not been proved that merit has been affected. Tamilnadu has 69 per
cent reservation in government jobs and that is one of the best
governed states and its health index is highest in the country.
The proportion of SC/ST employees in the private sector does not
reflect their population in many of industrialised states, according
to the CII survey. For Example, in Karnataka SC/ST population is 22.8
per cent but their representation in jobs is only 9 per cent in
private sector and thus there is huge gap of 13.9 per cent. Indian
Industry unveiled a voluntary code of conduct for affirmative action
to provide job opportunities in the private sector for SC/ST but
performance has been quite dismal.
According to the CII 's own estimates, affirmative action agenda drawn
up by nearly 100 of its member companies have made a difference to the
lives of just 37,435 SC/STs over the past three years and this is like
a drop in the ocean in a country of 1.2 billion people.
The UPA-I promised to give reservation in private sector but that
remained a mirage and efforts at three levels like Group of Ministers
Committee, Coordination Committee in PMO and Group of Officers
Committee in the Ministry of Commerce and Industry were tried but that
resulted in nothing. The government was urged that it must introduce
reservation in private sector as is prevalent in government service.
Nearly for two decades, the higher judiciary has been diluting the
rights given by Parliament and other legislative bodies to these
sections. In 1997, five anti-reservations orders were issued and that
was also due to pronouncement of higher judiciary. On January 4, 2011,
the Lucknow High Court struck down the right of reservation in
promotion. Rajasthan High Court has also done the same.
This is a very sorry state of affairs that whatever the legislature
gives is being snatched by the higher judiciary. To restore the
benefit of reservation in promotion, the government must bring about
Constitutional amendments. In this background, the demand for
reservation in higher judiciary is strongly justified. The UPA-I
promised to enact the Reservation Act and the bill was introduced in
the Rajya Sabha in 2004 but so far, it has not been passed. Without an
effective Reservation Act, it is not possible to implement
reservation. This is one of the reasons that huge backlog in
employment of SC/ST/OBC to government posts is created. The government
has recently promised to fill up the backlog and let us see what
The contract system is not only increasing exploitation but also
affecting the jobs and quality of life. Safai Karmacharies are the
worst sufferers and without stopping the contract system and
introducing time bound promotion, their lives are not going to be
improved. Many deserving candidates are not getting their due because
of difficulties in availing the caste certificates. The caste
certificate of one state is not valid in other states and as a result
either posts are lying vacant or benefit of reservation is being
reaped by others. Thus the order of 1950 is to be annulled.
Besides Dr.Udit Raj other office bearers of Confederation from all
over the country Indira Athawale, Bhawan Nath Paswan, Dr. Anil Kumar,
SU Gadpyle, Nitin Gangurde, Maha Singh Bhurania, S.P. Jaravta, Phool
Singh Gautam , Jasbir Singh Pal, Darshan Singh Chanded, Net Ram
Thagela, Brahm Prakash, Vinod Kumar, A. R. Koli, Raghubir Singh, G.D.
Diwakar, M.L. Deepak, P. R. Meena , Satya Pal Bauddh, Indraj Singh,
Shyam Babu Rawat, R.V. Singh, Balbirchand Bauddh, H.C. Arya, Jaipal
Singh, Hira Lal, D.K. Behera, Shankhanand, Anchal Das, G.C. Dalai,
Narayan Charan Das, Param Hans Prasad, R.B. Singh, K.P. Roy, R.S.
Maurya, Ambalal Chauhan, Ramesh Manwar, B. Sagadevan, M.
Jagpriyapathi, M. Jagannathan, Shiv Bhagya Rao, K. Raman Kutty, Madhu
Chandra, Maheshwar Raj, G. Shankar, Prem Kumar, Anil Meshram, Pradeep
Sukhdeve, Tarapad Biswas, Rameshwar Ram, Sapan Haldar, Dinesh Kumar,
Damodar Bauddh, Shankar Tanti, Madhusudan Kumar , R.K. Kalsotra ,
Madan Ram, Devi Prasad, Purushottam Das, J. Shriniwaslu, S. Rajendran,
M. Vendakswamy, M.R. Negi etc, and leaders of other organisations like
Mastram Kapur, Ibrahim Qureshi, Dilip Mandal, P. S. Krishnan, Vinod
Diwakar, Vinod Kumar, Prabuddh Kumar, Chandrapal Singh, Rahul Kumar,
Joseph D'Souza, Ravi Varma Kumar, MR Gyasi, Yusuf Ansari, Aziz Burney,
Ivan Kostaka, Abraham Mathai, M.A. Siddiqe, Sunil Sardar, Bishop M. S.
Scaria, Subba Rao, Hani Babu, Devidayal, Akhilesh Katiyar, V. P.
Nagar, Pawan Yadav, B. S. Yadav, Sanjay Kanaujia etc. addressed the
rally and pledged to come back again and again till these rights are
Get all ZESTCaste mails sent out in a span of 24 hours in a single mail. Subscribe to the daily digest version by sending a blank mail to ZESTMediafirstname.lastname@example.org, OR, if you have a Yahoo! Id, change your settings at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/join/
On this list you can share caste news, discuss caste issues and network with like-minded anti-caste people from across India and the world. Just write to email@example.com
TELL FRIENDS TO SIGN UP:-
If you got this mail as a forward, subscribe to ZESTCaste by sending a blank mail to ZESTCastefirstname.lastname@example.org OR, if you have a Yahoo! ID, by visiting http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/join/
Also have a look at our sister list, ZESTMedia: http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/