Dalit Socialists Via Dalit Capitalists: A Response To Anand Teltumbde
Marxism is Refuge For Brahmins By- Nagesh Chaudhary
The debate on Dalit capitalism is being discussed by some well known Dalit
writers and activists. My observation is - as long as caste system,
untouchability is alive in India Dalits cannot become capitalists. Even OBC
capitalists are Shudras and they (Shudras) cannot succeed unless they serve the
upper castes or Brahmins. Mr. Teltumde is in the company of upper caste
Marxists. Marxism is the refuge of Brahmins in India. My observation is, as you
climb the caste model you find increasing number of Marxists. In Maharashtra for
example, you will find Dalits as supporters in Toto of Jotirao Fule and his
Satyashodhak movement. Acceptance to his ideology decreases as you go upward in
the caste hierarchy. Dalits, OBC follow Fule but Marathas do it with
reservations. For example Sharad Patil, a Maratha and one time card holder of
CPI(M), does not accept Fule completely. He supplements Fule with Marx. Baba
Adhao, a socialist Maratha accepts Fule attaching Progressive word to Fule's
Satyashodhak movement. He runs 'Purogami Satyashohak' magazine in Marathi.
Sharad Patil edited for some years the Marathi monthly 'Styashodhak Marxwadi'.
(Satyashodhak movement was launched by Fule and his confidents in 1873 which was
against Brahman domination.)
When you come up in the caste ladder- to Brahmins, they do not consider Fule at
all. Brahmins consider accepting Fule or Ambedkar with Marx as inferior ideology
or contamination of Marx. They considered them as stooges of British imperialism
and that was and is the view of RSS Brahmins, too.
As Marxism is an ideology for classless society and does not touch upon the
caste system. It is helpful to maintain the caste hierarchy and also talk of
classless society. Brahmins feel safe in Marxism as it does not touch caste
system. Dr. B R Ambedkar's observation, -'priestly Brahmins and secular Brahmins
are arms the same body and if one is injured other comes to its rescue.'
Upper caste capitalists in India are under the Brahmanic governing class. So, no
capitalists can oppose Brahmins; on the contrary they respect Brahmanism. If
Dalits want to become capitalists they will have to fore go the ideology of
annihilation of Caste. Why Jain capitalists started adoring Brahmanism is for
this. Become capitalists but under our cultural control. (Jainism was one time
against Hinduism but now subscribes to it completely.) So the idea of Dalit
capitalism can not be a reality in the present system which is Brahmin dominated
or when as said by Dr. Ambedkar that in India 'governing class consists of
Brahmins and Banias' The process of becoming governing class or changing the
present system to that of casteless system is the precondition. Only when Dalits
will win the war against caste system then only they will be able to become
capitalists. Capitalism with castes is contradictory. No crusader against caste
has thought of capitalism because it supports class division and class division
will not entirely abolish caste.
----- Original Message ----
From: Siddhartha Kumar <mailsiddhartha.k@gmail.com>
To: zestcaste <zestcaste@yahoogroups.com>
Sent: Wed, 9 March, 2011 1:31:05 PM
Subject: [ZESTCaste] Dalit Socialists Via Dalit Capitalists: A Response To Anand
Teltumbde
http://www.countercurrents.org/karthick080311.htm
Dalit Socialists Via Dalit Capitalists: A Response To Anand Teltumbde
By Karthick RM
08 March, 2011
Countercurrents.org
This article is intended as a response to Anand Teltumbde Dalit
Capitalism And Pseudo Dalitism on Countercurrents dated 7th March,
2011
Fanon writes in The Wretched of the Earth that in colonies, a person
is rich because he is white and he is white because he is rich. Simply
put, the superstructure is the base. Stretching this analysis to
India, one can argue that a Dalit is poor because she is untouchable
and she is untouchable because she is poor. In a society like ours
where hierarchy receives ritual sanction and operates via the medium
of not only religion, but also language, social customs, morality and
of course, the state, social capital determines economic capital. Nay,
social capital is economic capital. If one has a glance at the top 50
'dollar billionaires' in India one finds that there are 2-3 OBC's in
the list. No Dalits at all. Most of the rest are brahmins or baniyas.
Is this capitalism in the classical sense?
Of course as Mr. Teltumbde says "capital does not have race, religion,
caste, creed or even country." But the capitalist has. What is capital
without the capitalist? What struggle against capitalism can be
successful unless it is directed against the face, all too human face,
that embodies it? If we were to purely study the structure of capital
subtracting the human agency that drives it one would just drive down
an Althusserian blind alley. No. Capitalism has a human face and it is
shaped by the thoughts, opinions and prejudices of the actor. In
India, the face of the capitalist is the face of his caste.
Since Mr. Teltumbde is an avowed Marxist, I presume that he believes
that socialism follows/should follow capitalism. Presuming that he is
a Leninist, I believe that he would agree that the working class
requires its organic intellectuals both in and out of a revolutionary
party. In the history of Marxist intellectuals, very rarely have there
been any who have actually emerged from an authentic proletarian
background. They were bourgeois or petty-bourgeois who gave themselves
up intellectually to the cause of the working class. India will be no
exception to this. Where India will be an exception is that the caste
of the intellectual will matter as much as, probably more than, his
class. Here I would ask Mr. Teltumbde to look at various Marxist
intellectuals in the country and their caste-class background. One
does find a alarmingly high percentage of upper-caste adherents to a
philosophy that intends to break all hierarchies. This not at all to
doubt the intentions of the political actors concerned. Of course,
various Maoist party intellectuals like Anuradha and Kobad Ghandy have
taken genuine efforts to deal with caste. Yet, the question is why so
many of them to analyse an experience that they can never feel? Can't
the subaltern think?
A partial answer lies here. We are dealing with a class of
intellectuals that have had a middle class and bourgeois background to
which the social capital of caste did contribute. Being literate
sections for generations (rarely performing the gruelling tasks of
manual labour), they have had access to a decent standard of education
both at schools and more importantly, at home, besides day to day
interaction in a more sophisticated intellectual culture. The texts of
Marxism are not far from the reach of those that can read a text. Only
the intention is required and the resources are given. But the void of
Dalit and backward caste intellectuals in Marxism is precisely due to
the fact that the social conditions around their caste rarely provide
them the cultural and economic resources for them to first get a
decent education and concurrently engage with and absorb a philosophy
that changes them into conscious actors. Crudely put, the lack of a
sizeable petit-bourgeois and bourgeois class of Dalits reflects on
their minimal representation in Marxist circles.
Which is why Dalit Capitalism needs to be welcomed albeit partially.
It does have its flaws in that the involved actors do consider it as
the final stage of Dalit liberation, which is, of course, an act of
bad faith. But there is always the possibility of positive effects on
members the community, let us say, the children of the Dalit
capitalist, relatives or friends who might become beneficiaries out of
a sense of caste solidarity of the Dalit capitalist. More Dalits get
access to education and a different culture that they were previously
denied. From here on, it is a matter of choice on what politics they
seek to enter. But when they do enter, they enter not as objects, but
as knowing subjects adding their experiences, their knowledge, their
visions to a theoretical framework. One cannot expect that all might
make the right choice, that is, the left choice. But the opportunity
should be given to them to choose their political and intellectual
destinies.
In Philosophy of Hinduism, Ambedkar writes that genuine liberty must
be accompanied by three factors (I) Social equality (II) Economic
security (III) Universal knowledge. We know that none of these are
available in India for the Dalits. We can argue that economic
security, even if it is for a miniscule number of Dalit capitalists,
can and will open up possibilities for knowledge accumulation for a
greater number, which consequently open up newer avenues for Dalit
actors in movements for social equality. Caste is not just a social
category. It is an experience. Unless you have representation from all
caste groups to articulate those experiences in theory and execute
them in revolutionary praxis what one would actually end with, I fear,
is a group of upper castes performing the revolution, their
revolution, in the name of the backward castes and the Dalits. The
point is this: Dalit capitalism needn't be glorified the way its
protagonists have for it is not an end in itself. Yet, it needn't be
denounced the way Mr. Teltumbde does.
Karthick RM is a student-activist based in JNU, pursuing Masters in
History. He is associated with the Delhi Tamil Students Union, a
Periyarite-Marxist group.
------------------------------------
----
INFORMATION OVERLOAD?
Get all ZESTCaste mails sent out in a span of 24 hours in a single mail.
Subscribe to the daily digest version by sending a blank mail to
ZESTMedia-digest@yahoogroups.com, OR, if you have a Yahoo! Id, change your
settings at http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/join/
PARTICIPATE:-
On this list you can share caste news, discuss caste issues and network with
like-minded anti-caste people from across India and the world. Just write to
zestcaste@yahoogroups.com
TELL FRIENDS TO SIGN UP:-
If you got this mail as a forward, subscribe to ZESTCaste by sending a blank
mail to ZESTCaste-subscribe@yahoogroups.com OR, if you have a Yahoo! ID, by
visiting http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/join/
Also have a look at our sister list, ZESTMedia:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/Yahoo! Groups Links
----
INFORMATION OVERLOAD?
Get all ZESTCaste mails sent out in a span of 24 hours in a single mail. Subscribe to the daily digest version by sending a blank mail to ZESTMedia-digest@yahoogroups.com, OR, if you have a Yahoo! Id, change your settings at
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/join/ PARTICIPATE:-
On this list you can share caste news, discuss caste issues and network with like-minded anti-caste people from across India and the world. Just write to zestcaste@yahoogroups.com
TELL FRIENDS TO SIGN UP:-
If you got this mail as a forward, subscribe to ZESTCaste by sending a blank mail to ZESTCaste-subscribe@yahoogroups.com OR, if you have a Yahoo! ID, by visiting
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTCaste/join/ Also have a look at our sister list, ZESTMedia:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/ZESTMedia/ 
